Successfully complete one of the following tasks to get a trophy:
- Fully Decorated (Gold): Earn all of the Badges.
- Fastest gun in the west (Silver): Beat Wes Flowers.
- Consistently quick (Silver): Get a fastest time of .50 or less for 20 shooters.
- There's a new Sheriff in town (Silver): Beat the tournament on Sheriff difficulty.
- Quick Draw (Silver): Get a draw time of .30 or less.
- Two for one (Silver): Defeat all the shooters who come in pairs.
- BOOM! Hat Shot! (Bronze): Shoot off Junction Jack's lucky hat.
- Pistols at dawn (Bronze): Finish either 2 player mode.
- Six shooter (Bronze): Beat your friend in a 2 player game 6-0.
- I shot first... (Bronze): Defeat any shooter.
Additionally, there is one secret trophy:
- Premature (Bronze): Foul Out.