Successfully complete one of the following tasks to get a trophy:
- Into the Light (Bronze): Escape the garbage can.
- Grim Reaper (Silver): Sacrifice 1,000 followers.
- Collector (Silver): Collect all the Secrets in the game.
- BFF (Bronze): Complete a level in co-op.
- Candy Skillz (Bronze): Complete a non-boss level without dying.
- It's a Sour life (Silver): See 8 different Sour Sacrifices in a single level.
- Sugar Addict (Silver): Earn a Campaign Score greater than 300,000.
- I'm Alive! (Bronze): Earn a score greater than 50,000 in a single level.
Additionally, there are four secret trophies:
- If the Shoe Fits... (Bronze): Beat Semi-Squished.
- Crybaby (Bronze): Beat Dolly-Doll.
- Eviction Notice (Bronze): Beat Pump-Kind.
- Destiny (Gold): Beat the game.