Successfully complete one of the following tasks to get a trophy:
- Leave Possible? (Platinum): Collect all trophies.
- "This House is Clear" (Gold): Complete the Story.
- Adler Letters, Pt. 1 (Silver): Collect 4 of Maggie's letters.
- Adler Letters, Pt. 2 (Gold): Collect 8 of Maggie's letters.
- Adler Letters, Pt. 3 (Gold): Collect all of Maggie's letters.
- Ghost Stories (Gold): Find all hidden frequencies.
- It's A Me (Silver): Jump the crazy chasm in the woods.
- Renjamin Spanklin (Gold): Slap Ren in the face.
Additionally, there are six secret trophies:
- Thicker than Water (Gold): Bring Michael back from the dead.
- New Beginnings (Gold): Jonas is your new step brother.
- I'm the Firestarter (Gold): Make enemies with all of your friends.
- Matchmaker (Gold): Get Ren and Nona to date.
- You'd Just End Up Hating Each Other (Silver): Keep Ren and Nona from dating.
- The Strong, Silent Type (Gold): Play the whole game without saying anything.