Successfully complete one of the following tasks to get a trophy:
- The 0.01 Percent Solution (Bronze): Got one one ten thousandth of the way through the alternate solution to the Cochlea puzzle.
- Frequent Tuber (Bronze): Used all the Bile Tubes in all directions.
- I'm So Faced (Bronze): Tried every possible Face-Off feature.
- Bongo Baby, Yeah (Bronze): Played the bongos repeatedly.
- Meet Murray (Bronze): Introduced Murray to everyone.
- The Newlyfed Game (Silver): Convinced DeCava that Guybrush is married to Morgan.
- There is a Brotherhood of Jerks (Silver): Accepted into the Brotherhood.
- La Esponja... Grande? (Silver): Acquired La Esponja Grande.
- Lord of the Locket (Silver): Tried every Locket Combination.
- What a Card (Silver): Tried every Tarot Card combination.
- Feed the Beast (Gold): Defeated DeCava and the Brotherhood.