Successfully complete one of the following tasks to get a trophy:
- Meals Fit for a King... Queen... Whatever (Bronze): Gave the MerLeader every kind of bait.
- She's Cute When She's Angry (Bronze): Get Morgan angry by repeatedly checking out the mast.
- Fishing for Literalists (Bronze): Caught a Red Herring.
- Talk to the Hook (Bronze): Threatened a number of adversaries with a Hook.
- Nice Try (Bronze): Heard the Secret of Donkey Island.
- Give Her a Hand (Silver): Kicked LeFlay off the Screaming Narwhal.
- Artifacts of LIfe (Silver): Get all of the Summoning Artifacts.
- Mighty Merperson Rescuer (Silver): Save the MerLeader from McGillicutty.
- Model of E-FISH-Ency (Silver): Read every fish joke.
- Ride 'Em, Pirate (Silver): Made LeChuck do something embarassing on the cliff.
- The BIG Finish (Gold): Sailed to the alleged resting place of La Esponja Grande.