Successfully complete one of the following tasks to get a trophy:
- Unvarnished Truth (Silver): Collect all Nuggets of Truth.
- The Tally (Bronze): Complete all Arcade missions.
- Magnificent Three (Bronze): Score the maximum of 3 stars in any Arcade mission.
- Legend Among Legends (Silver): Get all Arcade Mode stars.
- For a Few Skills More (Silver): Unlock all skills in Story Mode.
- Perseverance (Bronze): Unlock both exclusive weapons in a single category of skills in Story Mode.
- Trick Shot (Bronze): Kill a bird during a winning duel.
- Quality Time (Bronze): Fight in Concentration for 15 minutes.
- Ungrateful (Bronze): Shoot a flying stick of dynamite and the one who threw it on a single Concentration.
- Turkey Shoot (Bronze): Reach combo level of 20.
- Grows In The Telling (Silver): Complete the Story on hard difficulty.
- True Story (Bronze): Find all Nuggets of Truth in a single mission.
- Keep At It (Bronze): Unlock a skill.
Additionally, there are four secret trophies:
- This Time for Real (Bronze): Give it to them straight about your meeting with Pat Garrett.
- Into the Sunset (Bronze): Forgive your lifetime nemesis.
- Violence Begets Violence (Bronze): Kill your lifetime nemesis honorably in a duel.
- For Massive Damage (Bronze): Shoot through a hole to kill an enemy that hides behind a shield.