Successfully complete one of the following tasks to get a trophy:

Tales High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on Tales of the Arabian Nights.
Tales Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on Tales of the Arabian Nights.
Tales Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on Tales of the Arabian Nights.
Ripley's High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on Ripley's Believe it or Not!
Ripley's Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on Ripley's Believe it or Not!
Ripley's Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on Ripley's Believe it or Not!
Theatre High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on Theatre of Magic.
Theatre Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on Theatre of Magic.
Theatre Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on Theatre of Magic.
Black Hole High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on Black Hole.
Black Hole Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on Black Hole.
Black Hole Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on Black Hole.

The following trophies require the "Cirqus Voltaire And Funhouse" bonus downloadable content:

Cirqus High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on Cirqus Voltaire.
Cirqus Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on Cirqus Voltaire.
Cirqus Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on Cirqus Voltaire.
Funhouse High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on Funhouse.
Funhouse Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on Funhouse.
Funhouse Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on Funhouse.

The following trophies require the "Creature From The Black Lagoon And Black Knight" bonus downloadable content:

Creature High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on Creature from the Black Lagoon.
Creature Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on Creature from the Black Lagoon.
Creature Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on Creature from the Black Lagoon.
Knight High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on Black Knight.
Knight Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on Black Knight.
Knight Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on Black Knight.

The following trophies require the "Elvira And The Party Monsters And No Good Gofers" bonus downloadable content:

Elvira Party High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on Elvira and the Party Monsters.
Elvira Party Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on Elvira and the Party Monsters.
Elvira Party Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on Elvira and the Party Monsters.
Gofers High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on No Good Gofers.
Gofers Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on No Good Gofers.
Gofers Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on No Good Gofers.

The following trophies require the "Harley Davison And Taxi" bonus downloadable content:

Harley High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on Harley Davidson.
Harley Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on Harley Davidson.
Harley Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on Harley Davidson.
Taxi High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on Taxi.
Taxi Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on Taxi.
Taxi Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on Taxi.

The following trophies require the "Medieval Madness And The Machine: Bride Of Pin-Bot" bonus downloadable content:

Bride High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on The Machine: Bride of Pin-Bot.
Bride Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on The Machine: Bride of Pin-Bot.
Bride Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on The Machine: Bride of Pin-Bot.
Medieval High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on Medieval Madness.
Medieval Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on Medieval Madness.
Medieval Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on Medieval Madness.

The following trophies require the "Monster Bash And Gorgar" bonus downloadable content:

Gorgar High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on Gorgar.
Gorgar Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on Gorgar.
Gorgar Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on Gorgar.
Monster Bash High 5 (Bronze): Achieve a top 5 local high score on Monster Bash.
Monster Bash Master (Silver): Complete the Standard Goals on Monster Bash.
Monster Bash Wizard (Silver): Complete the Wizard Goals on Monster Bash.