MLB The Show 17 Review for PlayStation 4 (PS4)

MLB The Show 17 Review for PlayStation 4 (PS4)

MLB The Show 17 Pitches a No-Hitter in the franchise’s Best Title Yet

This year’s installment of MLB The Show is certainly a special one for me. For starters, perhaps my generation’s most polarizing player, Ken Griffey Jr., graces the cover and rightfully props the Retro Mode. Secondly, my Cubbies finally broke the longest championship drought in the history of modern sports. I hugged my old man and braced for the ground beneath us to split into two, signifying the end of the world as we knew it. Fortunately, the world didn’t end and the Cubs still rightfully owned the World Series trophy when I woke up the following morning. Finally, MLB The Show 17 brought me right back to the 200-level seats in Wrigley Field, as a young version of myself sat gleefully with his beat up old Cubs hat and oversized mitt passed down from my older brother. This year’s edition is without a doubt the greatest baseball simulator ever created and reminds us exactly why we journeyed to the ballpark in the first place.

After spending some quality time with MLB The Show 17 , I’m really impressive with the title from top to bottom. To be perfectly honest, I was a bit skeptical the game would live up to expectations, especially since MLB The Show 16 was such a significant milestone for the franchise. It literally tied up every loose end from MLB The Show 15 – clunky gameplay, shallow game modes, and an average presentation – and finally brought it all together. At least, that’s what we thought last year, until now. In true Sony fashion, they never cease to defy expectations as MLB The Show 17 goes above and beyond.

I won’t bury the lead on this one, although I may have already done so as I’m nearly 300 words in. Nevertheless, MLB The Show 17 ’s most captivating addition is the completely revamped Road to The Show. This “live the life” game mode, dubbed Pave Your Path, has been overhauled in favor of a documentary-style presentation. Player’s choices, both on and off the field, will have bearing on their future as a baseball pro. This nonlinear model is truly unique to the player and will bend and flex as choices are made from Single-A all the way up through the majors. You can take the advice of your minor-league advisor as you work your way into the greatest right fielder in history, or tell him to pound sand and do it your own way – the choice is entirely up to you.

MLB The Show 17 Review Screenshot

You’ll see a few twists and turns along that way that will either harden you into a solid pro or expose your weaknesses and keep you locked in the minors until your contract becomes null and void. From the very get-go, your Road to The Show player will be challenged and it will be your call on how you handle yourself. Be careful though, your first meeting with your new GM might just land back in Juco. Either path you decide to take will present an entirely unique offering that hasn’t quite been perfected by MLB’s predecessors. This game mode should provide some authentic drama along the road to becoming the best. Either go for glory or settle for career minor leaguer – it seemed to work for my old buddy from high school.

MLB The Show 17 Review Screenshot

The MLB The Show 17 core gameplay has been further refined this year with several additional bat animations added, three separate control types for each facet of the game, and a brand new set of field throwing mechanics, which are much more efficient and accurate this time around. Ball physics, in particular, have also been significantly upgraded as well. Curving and slicing grounders shooting down both the first and third baseline are present, along with bloops, the always-frustrating Texas-leaguer, and the short-stop’s nightmare of topspin line drives. Ball physics also include a brand new varied ball path system, which actually takes into account bat speed, pitch type, and velocity when determining the ball’s outcome. It’s unreal to think the game’s engine calculates all that with flawless effort. The gameplay upgrades alone are worth the price of admission.

The visuals across the board have taken another positive step forward, from the several thousand player-animations, the upgraded broadcast package, and even the detail of the stadiums. Every ballpark, from Fenway Park to Dodgers Stadium and everything in between, are just as beautiful in the game as they are in real life. MLB The Show 17 does a fantastic job of replicating the feeling of actually being at the ballpark by getting every detail of the stadium down, even the placement of security officials. The improved fans blanketing each game adds another layer of depth to the visuals, as they’ve been retrofitted with new animations, new gear, and a variety of new models.

MLB The Show 17 Screenshot

Retro Mode is a nice addition to this year’s installment, which essentially takes everything from the main game and boils it down into a Sega-style baseball simulator. This is exactly where the Ken Griffey Jr. piece comes into play. Players control nearly every aspect of the game through the “X” button while experiencing the joy of classic 8-bit sound and textual graphics. The old school home run jingle reminds you exactly what it felt like to play World Series Baseball back in 1993. Although minor in the grand scheme of things, Retro Mode is a unique additional that reminds us just how far the genre has come.

MLB The Show 17 as a collective whole, from a controls, presentation, and core game mode perspective, is incrementally better. That might seem like a negative but, in fact it’s a huge positive. Nothing kills a franchise more than when the developers deciding to revamp everything and start fresh. MLB The Show 17 takes a progressive, but tactful, step forward. The aforementioned enhancements are exactly that, improvements that truly make the game better. Rather than shooting for the moon and burning up on the Sun, MLB The Show 17 calls out it’s home run and knocks a dinger over the left field wall like it was nothing. This game is truly a delight and a must have for anyone who enjoys baseball simulations, even if you are an Indians fan.

America’s favorite pastime is perfectly captured in the beautifully defined visuals. 5.0 Control
Charging a ground ball from the outfield and lasering a guy out at 3rd base never felt so satisfying. 5.0 Music / Sound FX / Voice Acting
Bringing on Harold Reynolds and Dan Plesac to any already stellar cast was a genius move that plays off in the end. 5.0 Play Value
Fully expanded core game modes along with Retro Mode and Road to The Show make this year’s version robust. 4.9 Overall Rating – Must Buy
Not an average. See Rating legend below for a final score breakdown.

Review Rating Legend
0.1 – 1.9 = Avoid 2.5 – 2.9 = Average 3.5 – 3.9 = Good 4.5 – 4.9 = Must Buy
2.0 – 2.4 = Poor 3.0 – 3.4 = Fair 4.0 – 4.4 = Great 5.0 = The Best

Game Features:

  • Road to The Show: Take complete control in our RPG mode, with new opportunities to make decisions on AND off the field that change the path of your career.
  • Retro Mode: A retro-sim inspired game play experience that pays homage to the classic baseball games many of us grew up on.
  • Year-To-Year Saves: No need to start over your Road to The Show career or Franchise from ’16 when you can bring them into The Show 17 with Year-To-Year Saves. Your saves in ’17 will carry over to 18, so play without worry of losing your progress.

  • To top