NHL 12 Review for PlayStation 3 (PS3)

NHL 12 Review for PlayStation 3 (PS3)

Flawlessly Balanced

For one reason or another, America has never fully embraced Ice Hockey with the love that most Canadians think it deserves. Many scientists hypothesize that this is a result of the innate distrust that Americans have for Canadians, but more research needs to be done on the topic before we’ll know for sure. Either way, EA seems to be bent on defying science, because they’ve released a new NHL title every year since 1991, and the franchise continues to be incredibly popular.

For the hockey illiterate out there (read: most Americans), EA’s NHL franchise was built on the pursuit of hockey realism. The developer wants to create the most realistic ice hockey experience on the market, and over the years they have spearheaded and perfected elements like analog stick-based puck control and “Be a Pro” mode. These elements have not only influenced subsequent NHL titles, but other games in the sports genre as well.

However, when it comes to video games, realism can often be a type of poison for gameplay. Obviously, Electronic Arts could never shrink wrap a perfectly authentic professional hockey experience. If they did, most players would probably end up in the emergency room on release day. Even so, I often worry that developers can become so fixated on realism that they sacrifice gameplay, but NHL 12 quickly put my mind at ease.

NHL 12 Screenshot

Because I value scientific inquiry, I assembled a crack team of research professionals in order to put NHL 12 through its paces. The team included a nationally ranked NHL 11 player, 2 drunks, and a 12-year-old kid. We spent several hours talking trash and hitting each other with virtual sticks. Here are the results of our study.

Right out of the first face-off, EA’s quest for realism is readily apparent; the game speed in NHL 12 is significantly slower than its predecessors. This is the type of thing that typically worries me about a developer’s pursuit of realism. Even if EA is trying to match pro hockey’s actual speed, the end result is going to be less accurate than a faster-paced caricature of reality, because that caricature captures the essence of hockey’s frenetic play more accurately than any realistic approach ever could. However, EA makes up for the slower game speed with their artificial intelligence improvements.

In past versions of NHL, non-human players would simply trail the puck. However, with EA’s new “Anticipation A.I.,” CPU players will go where the puck is going to be, not where it is. In my opinion, both of these are welcome changes that go hand in hand with one another, injecting a sense of urgency into every play. Every time the puck was loose, the pursuit was far more clamorous. Sure, the gameplay might be slower, but the excitement level is measurably higher.

For the last few months, EA has been touting a new “Full Contact Physics Engine” for NHL 12. When I first heard EA’s Sean Ramjagsingh brag about the engine, I must admit, I was a little skeptical. But after getting my hands on the game, the engine’s influence on gameplay was readily apparent. Now, when two players collide, both of their physical sizes are taken into account. Players of a similar size are more likely to simply stumble or get knocked down to a single knee. This stands in contrast to previous versions of the NHL series, in which all properly executed hits resulted in a player hitting the ice.

NHL 12 Screenshot

All of this may seem trivial, but NHL 12 has intricacies that make the Full Contact Physics Engine an instrumental part of the overall gameplay. For instance, one of my researchers (one of the drunks) was knocked down to a single knee and found that he could still maintain control over the puck and even shoot. And that’s not all. Players are able to break the glass, get their helmets knocked off, and knock the nets off the goals. Obviously, some of these changes were made purely for aesthetic reasons, but all of them can affect gameplay in extraordinarily subtle ways.

One of the other things that my research team latched onto was the addition of goalie fighting in NHL 12. That’s right. If, for some reason, you have a beef with the opposing team’s goalie, feel free to settle it like men. I was surprised by the excitement that the first goalie-related fistfight generated among the researchers, and I’m equally surprised that it’s taken EA so long to implement this feature. Goalies deserve to get punched, just like everyone else.

Speaking of goalies, screening has become far more useful tool in the offensive player’s toolbox. NHL 12 gives players significantly more control while screening. However, defensive A.I. has been added to protect the goalie. So, if you’re anything like the people on my crack research team, who constantly tormented the goalie by screening or picking fights, your players will probably spend some time on the injured list courtesy of the goalie’s bodyguard. All of this results in a far more realistic offensive and defensive experience.

NHL 12 Screenshot

This type of A.I. skill set for non-human players was actually a large part of the NHL 12 development process. In fact, the developers have gone so far as to implement player-specific characterizations, called “Signature Traits,” to ensure that each CPU player plays more like their real-life counterpart. Sean Ramjagsingh recently explained a few of these signature traits:

  • One-knee specialists – snipers; sharp-shooters; you can find these players shooting one-timers from one knee on the off-wing, e.g. Steven Stamkos, Corey Perry
  • Setup man – playmaker; loves to distribute the puck and is great at it, e.g. Henrik Sedin, Joe Thornton
  • Net agitators – kings of the front of the net; live for the tough areas and banging in garbage goals, e.g. Tomas Holmström
  • Drives the net – goes hard to the net to create rebounds, e.g. Ryan Kesler
  • Shoots on the rush – over the blue line, quick move then snipe, e.g. Alexander Ovechkin
  • Dump and chaser – your textbook 3rd and 4th line grinder; persistent and strong board play, e.g. Chris Neil, Aaron Asham

  • And there are many more signature traits where those come from. EA has managed to pack an incredible amount of depth into NHL 12’s gameplay. It’s almost a shame that a new one will hit the shelves in a mere 12 months.

    If you were a fan of the controls in NHL11, you’ll be perfectly comfortable in this latest incarnation. It’s a little bit more difficult to hit people and score, but all of the buttons and analog sticks should perform the same functions. If they don’t, you probably need a new controller.

    EA has also spent some time tweaking the Ultimate Hockey Team feature that they implemented last year. Basically, Ultimate Hockey League is like a fantasy hockey league that can be played via Xbox Live or PSN. This explanation might be a tad simplistic, considering how much thought must be put into every single decision in the UHT.

    NHL 12 Screenshot

    Ultimate Hockey Team tasks players with collecting players’ cards, assembling a team, and entering that team into the league. Players are allowed to trade or purchase new cards, but they need to pay attention to things like salaries, contract length, and chemistry. UHT was pretty popular in NHL 11, and I assume that the same will be true of 12. It’s a welcome distraction from the standard gameplay.

    And Legends mode actually affects many of the other game modes in NHL 12. Now players are able to play as (or play with) the biggest names that hockey has ever known. You’ll be able to play as Mario Lemieux, Wayne Gretzky, and many more.

    You will also be able to select legendary cards in Ultimate Hockey Team and put Wayne Gretzky into your multiplayer lineup. Obviously, this detracts from EA’s vision of overall realism, but we’ll give them a pass. Playing as Mario Lemieux totally makes up for it.

    NHL 12 is a welcome addition to the NHL family. EA has seemingly done the impossible by revamping the game in a way that not only increases the realism, but also improves the gameplay. NHL 12 also includes a few extras that are guaranteed to make it a fan favorite (like Legends, goalie fighting, and the Winter Classic). American hockey fans and pretty much all of Canada will not be disappointed by this title. So go pick it up if you want EA to continue defying science.

    Amazing attention to detail. 5.0 Control
    The same controls we’re all used to. If it ain’t broke… 4.5 Music / Sound FX / Voice Acting
    Perfectly executed. However, the announcers can get a little obnoxious. 5.0 Play Value
    Many will play it every day until NHL 13 is released. 4.7 Overall Rating – Must Buy
    Not an average. See Rating legend below for a final score breakdown.

    Review Rating Legend
    0.1 – 1.9 = Avoid 2.5 – 2.9 = Average 3.5 – 3.9 = Good 4.5 – 4.9 = Must Buy
    2.0 – 2.4 = Poor 3.0 – 3.4 = Fair 4.0 – 4.4 = Great 5.0 = The Best

    Game Features:

  • Full-Contact Physics Engine – From shattered glass and flying helmets to knocking players over the boards and into the bench, experience the skill and aggression of hockey like never before. Crash the crease too hard and you’ll knock the net off and send the goalie flying.
  • Be a Pro Revamped – Playing as your created pro, earn every shift on the ice with stellar play, big hits, and spectacular goals. Simulate the action to your next shift so you’re always on the ice as you play out your entire career gunning for the Stanley Cup
  • All-New Dynamic Goalie Interaction – Stonewall your opponents with awe-inspiring desperation saves from your goalie as he covers every possible angle and works through screens and flying players in front of the net.
  • Goalies Drop the Gloves – When the action boils over, send a message by leaving the net, dropping the gloves, and trading punches with a heated rival during fights.
  • Play in the Winter Classic – The NHL package jumps to life with the addition of the NHL Winter Classic, the league’s premier outdoor hockey event on New Year’s Day. Play under snowfall at Pittsburgh’s Heinz Field as 70,000+ rabid fans provide inspiration by cheering you on while donning Winter Classic gear.

  • To top