For the most part, Stardew Valley isn’t a title that focuses on heavy choices for the player. However, there are a few key choices you must make through the game, which impact how your build works in-game.
One of the choices comes at Level 5 Mining, when you’re asked to choose between Miner or Geologist. Both of these leveling paths give you a perk of their own. So which should you choose? We’re laying out all the benefits of Miner and Geologist in Stardew Valley, so you know which is best for you when the time comes to pick.
The Main Difference
The different professions in Stardew Valley only have one major difference, meaning there’s not actually all that much to consider when comparing Miner vs Geologist.
If you go down the Miner leveling path, you’ll be rewarded with +1 ore per vein during mining. On the other side, the geologist gives you a 50% chance that gems will appear in pairs.
What is most interesting about these perks is that they have a different impact, depending on what stage of the game you are in. There’s no right answer, and it will all depend on what you prioritize during gameplay. Let’s take a look at the perks of either side.
The Perks of +1 Ore Per Vein
Getting more ore per vein can be extremely powerful in the early game. It can help you gather far more resources in the long run, which will see you reach end-game content much faster. Because of this, it’s hard to underestimate the impact of earning +1 ore per vein via the Miner profession.
If nothing else, it’s a massive time saver, too. It won’t necessarily help you get more money in Stardew Valley, but it will remove a part of the game’s grind. On top of this, the Miner path sees you choose between two of the more lucrative paths in Blacksmith and Prospector at Level 10, which we’ll get into soon enough.
The Perks of a 50% Chance of Finding Two Gems
If you choose Geologist at Level 5 Mining, the game will produce a 50% chance of finding two gems while mining. Crucially, because you won’t always get a gem when you mine, and this means you’ll see the benefits of becoming a Geologist much less frequently than the Miner route.
In the early game, you won’t see too much benefit with this. The extra cash is nice, but probably won’t make a huge difference to your progress throughout the game. Where the Geologist really shines is in the late game. The choices can lead to you becoming a Gemologist (more on that soon), which makes the gems you obtain worth much more. Because of this, it can justify the Geologist path as a fantastic way to make money in Stardew Valley.
One More Choice
No matter which you choose between Miner or Geologist in Stardew Valley, the game will throw up one more choice at Level 10 in the Mining skill. The choices available to you actually depend on what you choose out of Miner vs Geologist, so it’s relevant to know when making your choice.
If you go down the Miner route, reaching Level 10 will open up the Blacksmith vs Prospector choice. The Blacksmith path makes all metal bars worth 50% more, while the Prospector route doubles your chance of finding coal.
Alternatively, becoming a Geologist opens up the Excavator and Gemolist paths at Level 10 Mining. Excavator doubles the chance of finding geodes, and the Gemologist path makes gems and minerals sell for 30% higher value.
After you’ve made your choice between Miner vs Geologist, you might find yourself with late-game regret. Perhaps the build hasn’t worked out quite as you’d hoped, and you’re wanting a change. Don’t worry – the game has you covered.
Head into the sewers in Stardew Valley, and find the Statue of Uncertainty. While there, you can switch professions for a fee of 10,000 gold. It’s not going to come cheap, but we think it’s worthwhile if it’s going to make you have a better time with the game.
There’s still one thing to be aware of. After using the Statue of Uncertainty, all of your bonuses from your previous levels will vanish.
Stardew Valley: Miner vs Geologist – The Full Picture
The choice between Miner vs Geologist in Stardew Valley is mostly defined by how both professions evolve over the course of the game. If you’re looking for a huge time-saver throughout the game, then it’s a no-brainer – Miner is the way to go here. However, if you don’t mind waiting a little while to reap the rewards of your labor, then Geologist is worth looking at.
We’re not here to sit on fences, though. Overall, if you can only choose one, we recommend you go with the Miner in Stardew Valley.